LangBay
Riddles in the Dark 12 Spotlight Series Magic: The Gathering card

Spotlight Series · 12 · Rare

Riddles in the Dark 12 price

Market price · Nonfoil · raw

$51.09
#7 most valuable tracked card in Spotlight Series

TCGplayer market price as of October 10, 2026 · see listings

Is it worth grading? Run the numbers
Set
Spotlight Series
Number
12
Rarity
Rare
Illustrator
Tomas Duchek
Released
August 28, 2026
Type
Instant

Riddles in the Dark 12 price history

LangBay started tracking this card's price recently. A daily price chart will appear here as history builds up.

Prices by finish

FinishMarket recent sales
Nonfoil$51.09
Foil$497.75

Raw, ungraded copies on TCGplayer. The market price tracks what copies actually sold for. Graded (PSA, CGC, BGS) copies sell at different prices.

Is Riddles in the Dark 12 worth grading?

It depends on the card's condition and the gap between graded and raw prices. At $51.09 raw, a grading fee and weeks of turnaround have to be covered by the odds of a high grade, not just the PSA 10 price. Check centering, corners, edges and surface first, then run the grading calculator with this card's raw price filled in.

Get a grade-or-sell verdict for your copy

Scan your Riddles in the Dark. LangBay pre-grades centering, corners, edges and surface from your photos, pulls sold comps for each PSA grade, and tells you in dollars whether to grade it or sell it raw.

Scan it free

More from Spotlight Series

See every tracked Spotlight Series card →